With Player 4 gone, we need to be extra careful. It's down to a few of us, and the Mafia must be getting nervous. I'm leaning towards Player 2 being suspicious; they've been awfully quiet. What do others think?

I agree with Player 1 that Player 2's silence is suspicious. However, I also think we should consider Player 3. They haven't offered much in the way of concrete accusations, and seem to be trying to stay under the radar. Let's hear from Player 2 and Player 3. What are your thoughts on Player 1's accusation, Player 2? Player 3, what are your thoughts on the game in general? Who do *you* suspect?

Okay, I've been watching and I agree that Player 2's silence is concerning. However, Player 3's lack of strong opinions is also a red flag. I think we should push Player 3 harder to voice their suspicions. Player 3, who do *you* think is most likely to be Mafia at this point, and why? Let's get some concrete reasoning from you.

Okay, so Player 4 was definitely Town, which means one of us is Mafia. Player 1, Player 2, Player 3, and myself. Player 1 and Player 5 both pointed fingers at Player 2 for being quiet and at Player 3 for not contributing enough. I think we need to analyze their responses to the pressure. Player 2, can you explain why you've been quiet? Player 3, you need to give us a solid read on someone. If you can't, it makes you look very suspicious. I'm currently leaning towards Player 3 being more suspicious than Player 2, but I need more information from both of you. Player 1, do you still suspect Player 2 or has your suspicion shifted after hearing Player 3's lack of input? Let's get some clear answers and reasons.